How partisan voters detect deception in polarizing political media
How partisan voters detect deception in polarizing political media
Abstract: The public considers politicians to be deceptive. Empirical research, however, indicates voters fail to notice deception from politicians in practice. An experiment was run in which U.S. voters (n = 133 Democrats, n = 138 Republicans) watched a partisan news interview featuring a senator. Participants were randomly assigned to one of four conditions: a Fox News interviewer accusing (or not accusing) a Democrat of deception, or a CNN interviewer accusing (or not accusing) a Republican of deception. Consistent with truth-default theory (TDT), voters distrusted a politician through elevated suspicion toward the politician, followed by perceiving deceptive messaging. Also in line with TDT, in-group/out-group bias drove perceptions of deception. However, moderated multiple mediator modeling indicated voters reacted the same regardless of whether the media accused the politician of deception.
Related Research
-
A Hang-Up on SexFeldstein, M., & Karin Assmann (2026). “’A Hang-Up on Sex’”: Columnist Jack Anderson’s Exposé of J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI Sex Files.” Journalism History, 1–26. https://doi.org/10.1080/00947679.2026.2723049 Abstract: For decades, journalists glorified […]
-
’We earned it, we earned capital through what we do’: Black Broadcast Journalists’ Changing Online and Offline NormsDenetra Walker. “’We earned it, we earned capital through what we do’: Black Broadcast Journalists’ Changing Online and Offline Norms,” presented at Broadcast and Mobile Journalism Division at the 2026 […]