Atoning vs. evading when caught transgressing: two multi-theory-based experiments investigating strategies for politicians responding to scandal
Atoning vs. evading when caught transgressing: two multi-theory-based experiments investigating strategies for politicians responding to scandal
David E Clementson, Wenqing Zhao (Ph.D. student), and Michael J Beatty, “Atoning vs. evading when caught transgressing: two multi-theory-based experiments investigating strategies for politicians responding to scandal,” Human Communication Research, Volume 50, Issue 4, October 2024, Pages 545–560, https://doi.org/10.1093/hcr/hqae015
Abstract: Politicians tend to try deflecting scandals. Based on an attribution theory-driven perspective on persuasion, however, politicians should proactively confess. In a preregistered, multiple-message design, we conduct controlled, random assignment experiments. A mediation model is tested. Inspired by crisis communication’s change-of-meaning concept, the first variable appraises the extent to which voters perceive that the messaging indicates the politician is engaging in a cover-up. The second linkage is the politician’s credibility. The outcome variable is voters’ behavioral intentions. In Experiment 1 (N = 905 U.S. voters), stealing thunder and apologizing outperform stonewalling, changing the subject, sequentially apologizing plus deflecting, or silence. Experiment 2 (N = 277) finds that, in a sex scandal, stealing thunder and apologizing continue to perform equally well. Our theoretical contribution resides in enhancing the explanatory power of theories designed to explain image repair, as well as empirically testing the independent and combined role of apology and stealing thunder.
Related Research
-
IDOLSNeil Landau is co-Executive Producer on the live action feature film IDOLS that completed production in Spain and is currently in post-production. Warner Bros is distributing in November 2025.
-
BUFFALO KIDSNeil Landau’s most recent animated feature film BUFFALO KIDS was nominated for a Gaudi Award in Spain.